When it comes to your dog’s health, few decisions are more important than choosing the right food. With a growing number of premium pet food brands promising better nutrition and better results, pet owners are often left overwhelmed. One such brand that has gained widespread attention in recent years is Dr. Marty’s Dog Food, a product line created by Dr. Martin Goldstein, a well-known holistic veterinarian. Marketed as a natural, raw-based, and species-appropriate diet, Dr. Marty’s has attracted praise from celebrity dog owners and enthusiastic customer reviews across social media and pet forums.
But is Dr. Marty’s dog food actually good for dogs? Is it backed by science? How does it compare to other premium and conventional dog foods on the market? This comprehensive review dives deep into Dr. Marty’s pet food — its ingredients, nutritional profile, manufacturing process, customer feedback, expert opinions, and overall value — to help you make an informed decision for your furry companion.
Who is Dr. Marty, and What is His Philosophy?
Dr. Marty Goldstein is a graduate of Cornell University’s College of Veterinary Medicine and has been practicing veterinary medicine for over four decades. He is a vocal advocate for holistic and integrative veterinary practices that incorporate acupuncture, homeopathy, chiropractic care, and natural nutrition. His philosophy centers around the belief that dogs thrive on a diet similar to what their ancestors ate in the wild — raw, natural, and minimally processed.
He developed his dog food line based on this philosophy, aiming to reformulate pet nutrition to align with ancestral diets. The core product, Dr. Marty Nature’s Blend, is a freeze-dried raw diet that claims to combine the benefits of a raw diet with the convenience of dry kibble.
Understanding Dr. Marty’s Dog Food Line
The most prominent offering in Dr. Marty’s lineup is Nature’s Blend Raw Freeze-Dried Dog Food, but the brand also offers targeted supplements and complete meal alternatives. Let’s take a closer look at the flagship product.
What is Nature’s Blend?
Nature’s Blend is a freeze-dried, raw-formulated dog food designed to resemble what wild canines might have consumed. It is promoted as a complete and balanced diet suitable for dogs of all life stages. Here’s what sets it apart:
- Freeze-dried raw format: Preserves nutrients better than heat processing
- Grain-free formula: Utilizes vegetables and fruits instead of corn, wheat, or soy
- Rich in protein: Features beef, chicken, lamb, turkey, and whitefish as primary ingredients
- Includes superfoods: Packed with berries, spinach, and other antioxidant-rich ingredients
- No artificial preservatives, colors, or fillers
The freeze-drying process removes moisture while preserving the nutritional integrity of raw ingredients. Unlike traditional kibble, which is often cooked at high temperatures and can degrade sensitive nutrients, freeze-drying maintains enzymes, vitamins, and proteins in a more natural state.
In-Depth Ingredient Analysis
To assess whether Dr. Marty’s food is truly good for dogs, we need to examine the ingredient list. According to the manufacturer, Here are the first ten ingredients in Nature’s Blend (in order):
- Beef
- Chicken
- Lamb
- Turkey
- Whitefish
- Egg
- Beef Liver
- Chicken Liver
- Organic Carrots
- Organic Flaxseed
Let’s break this down:
High-Quality Animal Proteins
Dogs are omnivores with a carnivorous bias — they require high levels of quality animal protein to maintain muscle mass, metabolic function, and overall vitality. Dr. Marty’s includes five animal protein sources in its top five ingredients, which is exceptional for any dog food. This diversity reduces the likelihood of food sensitivities and mimics the varied prey consumption of wild canines.
Animal organs like liver are also nutrient-dense, rich in vitamins A, B12, iron, and copper. Their inclusion is aligned with raw feeding philosophies.
Raw & Freeze-Dried: What’s the Difference?
While not truly “raw” in the sense of being unprocessed, freeze-dried food is rehydrated back to a raw-like state when prepared. The process involves freezing the raw ingredients and then placing them under a vacuum to remove ice through sublimation. This method preserves up to 97% of the original nutritional content, far better than conventional extrusion used in kibble.
Dr. Marty states that their product is never exposed to high heat, which helps maintain natural enzymes and amino acids critical to canine digestion and immune health.
Grain-Free with Functional Carbohydrates
Nature’s Blend is entirely grain-free, avoiding common allergens like corn, wheat, and soy. Instead, it uses vegetables like carrots, spinach, and broccoli, and fruits such as blueberries and cranberries. These ingredients provide fiber, antioxidants, and phytonutrients without the inflammatory potential of grains.
However, it’s worth noting that grain-free diets have come under scrutiny by the FDA. Some studies have linked grain-free diets high in legumes and potatoes to an increased risk of diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), particularly in certain breeds like Golden Retrievers and Doberman Pinschers. Dr. Marty’s does include peas and lentils (common in many grain-free formulas), so pet owners should be cautious if their dog has a history of heart issues.
Nutritional Profile: Does It Meet AAFCO Standards?
The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) sets nutritional standards for pet foods. Any product claiming to be “complete and balanced” should meet these benchmarks for a dog’s life stage (puppy, adult, or all life stages).
According to Dr. Marty’s website, Nature’s Blend is formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles for all life stages. Let’s analyze the guaranteed analysis:
| Nutrient | Content | AAFCO Minimum (Adult Maintenance) |
|---|---|---|
| Crude Protein (min) | 30% | 18% |
| Crude Fat (min) | 18% | 5% |
| Crude Fiber (max) | 5% | Not specified |
| Moisture (max) | 4% | Not specified |
The high protein and fat content make this food suitable for active dogs, pregnant or nursing females, and growing puppies. However, less active or senior dogs may require calorie management, and portion control becomes critical to prevent weight gain.
Potential Benefits of Dr. Marty’s Dog Food
Based on customer testimonials, nutritional analysis, and veterinary input, there are several reasons why Dr. Marty’s dog food is often praised:
Improved Coat and Skin Health
Many users report shinier coats, reduced shedding, and fewer skin irritations within a few weeks of switching to Nature’s Blend. This is likely due to the high levels of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids from flaxseed and fish, as well as the absence of common allergens.
Increased Energy Levels
Dogs on raw or raw-inspired diets often exhibit improved stamina, alertness, and playfulness. The nutrient-dense profile and the absence of empty fillers contribute to sustained energy and better metabolic efficiency.
Better Digestion and Smaller Stools
Because the food is highly digestible — with minimal indigestible bulk — owners commonly note smaller, firmer stools. This suggests that dogs are absorbing more nutrients and excreting less waste, a hallmark of a biologically appropriate diet.
Natural Immune Support
The inclusion of whole food ingredients like blueberries (antioxidants), turmeric (anti-inflammatory), and garlic (immune support in small amounts) can contribute to a stronger immune system over time. Dr. Marty avoids synthetic vitamins, relying instead on natural nutrient-dense sources, which some holistic practitioners believe are more readily utilized by the body.
Concerns and Criticisms
Despite its popularity and positive reviews, Dr. Marty’s is not without criticism. Here are some of the main concerns raised by experts and consumers:
Lack of Transparency in Lab Testing and Sourcing
While the ingredient list is public, Dr. Marty’s does not disclose detailed information about ingredient sourcing, manufacturing facilities, or routine third-party testing. Unlike some premium brands that publish batch-specific test results (like pathogen or contaminant testing), Dr. Marty’s maintains limited transparency, raising questions about consistency and safety.
High Price Point
At approximately $4 to $5 per pound when reconstituted, Dr. Marty’s is significantly more expensive than most kibbles or even canned foods. For large or multi-dog households, the cost can be prohibitively high over time. While the quality may justify the premium for some, it’s not accessible to everyone.
Rehydration Required — Added Inconvenience
Freeze-dried raw food requires rehydration with water before feeding. While this step enhances palatability and mimics a natural diet more closely, it adds an extra step that some owners find inconvenient, especially during travel or busy mornings.
Storage and Shelf Life Considerations
Once opened, the food must be used within about 4 weeks to prevent rancidity or loss of nutrients, especially since it lacks chemical preservatives. It must be stored in a cool, dry place — not ideal for humid environments.
What Do Veterinarians Say About Dr. Marty’s?
Opinions among veterinarians are divided. Board-certified veterinary nutritionists, often affiliated with veterinary schools, typically favor diets from companies with rigorous research, AAFCO feeding trials, and dedicated veterinary nutrition teams (e.g., Royal Canin, Hill’s Science Diet).
However, many integrative and holistic vets support Dr. Marty’s philosophy. They appreciate the high animal protein content, grain-free formulation, and elimination of artificial additives. Dr. Goldstein’s reputation in the holistic community adds credibility for these practitioners.
Still, concerns linger:
- Some vets warn that the diet may not be suitable for dogs with pre-existing medical conditions (e.g., kidney disease, pancreatitis) due to its high protein and fat content.
- The inclusion of garlic — while in “small amounts” — is controversial. Garlic is toxic to dogs in large quantities and may cause Heinz body anemia in sensitive individuals.
- Limited clinical studies directly linking Dr. Marty’s food to measurable health improvements remain absent.
Customer Reviews: What Are Pet Owners Saying?
Sifting through thousands of reviews on Amazon, Chewy, and the brand’s official site reveals a remarkably positive trend. Dr. Marty’s dog food consistently earns 4.7 to 4.9-star ratings, with many owners citing:
- Noticeable improvement in picky eaters
- Resolution of chronic digestion issues
- Weight management success
- Reduced vet visits and allergy-related symptoms
In one widely shared review, a Golden Retriever with chronic ear infections and loose stools reportedly saw complete symptom resolution within two months of switching to Nature’s Blend. Another user praised the food for giving their aging dog “a second wind,” with increased activity and mental sharpness.
However, some negative reviews mention:
- An initial transition period with loose stools or gassiness (common with dietary changes)
- Price-related affordability issues
- Dogs refusing the food despite rehydration efforts
- Allergic reactions (though rare, suggesting hidden sensitivities to specific proteins)
How Does Dr. Marty’s Compare to Other Raw and Premium Diets?
To better evaluate its standing, let’s compare Dr. Marty’s to other leading premium dog food brands:
| Brand | Format | Protein Sources | Price (per lb, rehydrated) | AAFCO Compliant | Key Differentiator |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Marty Nature’s Blend | Freeze-Dried | Beef, Chicken, Lamb, Turkey, Fish | $4.50 | Yes | Multi-protein, holistic approach |
| Stella & Chewy’s | Freeze-Dried | Singles or blends (e.g., chicken only) | $4.00 | Yes | No carrageenan, simple sourcing |
| Primal Pet Foods | Freeze-Dried & Frozen Raw | Rotational proteins, organic ingredients | $6.00 | Yes | Offers frozen raw; trusted sourcing |
| Orijen | Kibble | Biologically appropriate ratios | $3.80 | Yes | High meat inclusion, low carbohydrates |
| Royal Canin | Kibble & Canned | Engineered proteins | $2.50 | Yes | Veterinary-recommended, condition-specific |
Dr. Marty’s stands out for its diversity of meat sources and species-appropriate philosophy, but it’s not the only high-quality option. Competitors offer similar or better transparency, and some provide lower prices or veterinarian-backed formulations.
Final Verdict: Is Dr. Marty’s Good for Dogs?
After a thorough evaluation of ingredients, nutritional content, customer feedback, veterinary opinions, and cost, the answer is nuanced: For many dogs, Dr. Marty’s dog food can be a beneficial, high-quality diet — particularly for dogs with food sensitivities, picky eaters, or those transitioning from processed kibble to a more natural diet.
Pros:
- High concentration of animal-based proteins
- Freeze-dried technology preserves nutrients
- No artificial additives, fillers, or grains
- Positive real-world outcomes reported by many owners
Cons:
- Relatively high cost
- Limited transparency in sourcing and testing
- Not ideal for dogs with certain health conditions
- Rehydration required, which may deter some owners
The short answer: Yes, Dr. Marty’s dog food is generally good for dogs, especially healthy, active ones without underlying medical issues. However, it is not a universal solution. It’s important to consult your veterinarian before making a major dietary change, especially if your dog has health concerns.
Who Should Consider Dr. Marty’s?
This food may be ideal for:
- Dogs transitioning to a raw or natural diet
- Those with skin, coat, or digestive issues linked to kibble
- Active or working dogs needing high energy
- Pet owners seeking minimal-processed, whole-food nutrition
Who Should Be Cautious?
Consider alternatives if your dog:
- Has kidney or liver disease
- Is prone to pancreatitis (high fat content)
- Has a known sensitivity to any listed protein
- Requires a prescription diet
Practical Tips for Introducing Dr. Marty’s to Your Dog
If you decide to give Dr. Marty’s a try, follow these best practices:
Transition Gradually
Mix increasing amounts of Nature’s Blend with your current food over 7–10 days. This helps prevent gastrointestinal upset.
Always Rehydrate
Add warm (not hot) water to the food and let it sit for 5–10 minutes. Dr. Marty recommends a 1:1 ratio of food to water.
Monitor Your Dog’s Response
Keep an eye on stool quality, energy levels, coat condition, and any signs of allergies. If problems arise, consult your vet.
Store Properly
Keep the bag sealed in a cool, dry place. Avoid exposure to moisture and sunlight to maintain freshness.
Conclusion: A Premium Option with a Purpose
Dr. Marty’s dog food is not just another trendy pet product — it embodies a specific philosophy about animal health and nutrition rooted in holistic veterinary medicine. While it may not be the best choice for every dog or every budget, its emphasis on whole, raw-inspired ingredients and high-quality proteins makes it a compelling option for pet owners seeking a natural upgrade from conventional kibble.
The decision ultimately comes down to your dog’s individual needs, your veterinary guidance, and your confidence in the brand. Dr. Marty’s may not have the clinical research backing of veterinary prescription diets, but its real-world success stories and nutritional foundation suggest it is, for many dogs, a genuinely good choice.
If you’re looking to provide your dog with a nutrient-dense, minimally processed diet free of artificial ingredients and rich in animal protein, Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend is certainly worth considering — with informed caution.
What is Dr. Marty’s Dog Food made of?
Dr. Marty’s Dog Food, specifically the brand known as Dr. Marty Nature’s Blend, is composed of a freeze-dried raw formula that emphasizes natural, whole-food ingredients. The primary components include a mix of meats such as beef, chicken, turkey, and fish, all of which are sourced to be free from antibiotics and hormones. In addition to proteins, the formula incorporates a wide array of vegetables, fruits, and organ meats—like liver and kidney—intended to mimic a biologically appropriate diet for dogs. Vitamins and minerals are added without synthetic fillers, and no corn, wheat, soy, or artificial preservatives are included in the recipe.
This holistic approach is designed to deliver nutrients in their most natural state, preserving the integrity of proteins and enzymes through the freeze-drying process. Ingredients like spinach, cranberries, and garlic are included not only for nutritional value but also for their antioxidant and immune-boosting properties. By combining muscle meats, organ meats, and produce, Dr. Marty’s aims to offer a balanced, species-appropriate diet that supports overall canine health. The ingredient transparency and avoidance of common allergens make it a popular choice among pet owners seeking cleaner, more natural food options for their dogs.
Is Dr. Marty’s Dog Food truly raw?
Yes, Dr. Marty’s Dog Food is considered a raw diet due to its freeze-dried raw formulation. Unlike traditional kibble, which is highly processed with high heat that can degrade nutrients, Dr. Marty’s uses a freeze-drying method that preserves the raw state of the ingredients. This process involves quickly freezing the raw components and then removing moisture under vacuum conditions, which keeps the nutritional profile intact while allowing for shelf stability. As a result, the food retains naturally occurring enzymes, vitamins, and amino acids that are often lost in cooking.
However, it’s important to note that while the food starts as raw, the freeze-drying process does involve some minimal processing. Despite this, it remains significantly less processed than cooked or extruded dog foods. Once rehydrated with water, the food closely resembles a fresh raw diet, both in texture and nutritional content. Supporters argue this offers the benefits of raw feeding—such as improved digestion and coat health—without the challenges of storing and handling fresh raw meat. It’s a practical compromise for pet owners interested in raw nutrition but concerned about convenience and safety.
Are there any health benefits associated with Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend?
Numerous pet owners and veterinarians have reported various health benefits after switching dogs to Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend. These include shinier coats, increased energy levels, improved digestion, reduced stool volume and odor, and better dental health. The high-quality animal proteins and inclusion of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids from fish and flaxseed contribute to skin and coat condition, while the natural enzymes from raw ingredients aid gastrointestinal function. The absence of fillers and artificial additives also helps minimize food sensitivities and allergic reactions in many dogs.
Additionally, the formula includes superfoods like kelp, parsley, and blueberries, which are rich in antioxidants and support immune system function. Organ meats provide essential nutrients such as vitamin B12, iron, and CoQ10, contributing to overall vitality. Because the food is biologically appropriate and rich in nutrients, many dogs experience enhanced muscle development and better weight management. While individual results vary, especially based on breed, age, and pre-existing health conditions, the consensus is that this diet can significantly improve health markers when fed consistently and appropriately.
Has Dr. Marty’s Dog Food been recalled in the past?
As of now, Dr. Marty’s Dog Food—marketed under the brand name Natural Native Pets—has not had any official recalls reported by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or other regulatory bodies. This is a positive sign and reflects the brand’s commitment to safety and quality control during manufacturing. The company produces its food in a USDA-inspected facility using stringent hygiene and sourcing standards, which may contribute to its clean recall history. Transparency about sourcing and processing also builds consumer trust.
Still, absence of recalls does not automatically guarantee risk-free feeding. Raw or raw-inspired diets, including freeze-dried varieties like Dr. Marty’s, carry a theoretical risk of bacterial contamination such as Salmonella or Listeria, although the freeze-drying process reduces this risk significantly. Pet owners should follow proper handling instructions—such as washing hands and surfaces after preparation—and consult a veterinarian, especially when feeding puppies, senior dogs, or pets with compromised immune systems. Ongoing vigilance and monitoring by pet owners remain key components of safe feeding practices.
Is Dr. Marty’s Dog Food suitable for all dog breeds and life stages?
Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend is formulated to be nutritionally complete and balanced for all life stages, meaning it can be fed to puppies, adult dogs, and seniors. The high protein content and essential fatty acids support growth in young dogs, while the nutrient density benefits older dogs dealing with age-related issues like joint health and decreased energy. Because the formula contains a broad spectrum of vitamins and minerals from whole food sources, it aims to meet the varying needs of different breeds and sizes.
However, individual dogs may have specific dietary needs that aren’t addressed by a one-size-fits-all approach. For example, large-breed puppies require carefully controlled mineral levels to avoid skeletal issues, and dogs with medical conditions like kidney disease or pancreatitis may need veterinary-recommended diets. It’s always advisable to consult a veterinarian before making a significant diet change, especially for dogs with pre-existing health conditions. While Dr. Marty’s is generally safe for most dogs, tailored nutrition may be necessary for optimal health in some cases.
How does Dr. Marty’s compare to other freeze-dried dog foods?
Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend stands out in the freeze-dried dog food market due to its diverse ingredient list, which includes four types of meat, multiple organ meats, and a wide range of fruits and vegetables. Compared to other popular brands like Stella & Chewy’s or Primal, Dr. Marty’s emphasizes variety and includes more plant-based superfoods, which may appeal to owners seeking a holistic nutrition profile. Additionally, the brand highlights its use of antibiotic- and hormone-free ingredients, which aligns with consumer demand for cleaner pet food.
Price-wise, Dr. Marty’s is competitive but tends to be on the higher end, similar to other premium freeze-dried brands. Some users report better palatability and improved stool quality with Dr. Marty’s over other freeze-dried options, possibly due to the multi-protein, low-filler composition. However, the choice between brands often comes down to individual dog preferences and sensitivities. While some dogs thrive on Dr. Marty’s, others may prefer simpler protein sources offered by different brands. Reading labels and possibly doing a side-by-side trial can help determine the best fit.
What do veterinarians say about Dr. Marty’s Dog Food?
Veterinary opinions on Dr. Marty’s Dog Food are generally mixed, reflecting the broader debate around raw and raw-inspired diets. Some holistic or integrative veterinarians support the brand due to its high-quality ingredients, lack of artificial additives, and resemblance to a natural canine diet. They argue that raw nutrition can enhance digestion, immune function, and coat health—especially in dogs with food sensitivities. The freeze-dried format also appeals to vets who acknowledge the benefits of raw diets but are cautious about the risks of fresh raw feeding.
On the other hand, conventional veterinarians may express caution about potential bacterial contamination, nutritional imbalances if not fed properly, and the lack of extensive clinical studies backing long-term use. They also note that while ingredient quality is important, AAFCO nutritional adequacy statements and feeding trials are critical indicators of safety and balance. Some vets recommend Dr. Marty’s with the caveat that owners follow preparation guidelines carefully and monitor their pets closely for any adverse reactions. Ultimately, many veterinarians agree that individual dog needs should guide dietary choices, and professional consultation is advised.